top of page

"DBI is a page-turner, and that accolade carries to the very last page and the very last line."

A Book Review by New York Journal of Books. Charlie's Donlea's latest novel —Don't Believe It.

In 2007, Grace Sebold is arrested for killing boyfriend Julian Crist when she and her family attend the wedding of friends on the island of St. Lucia. There’s a swift arrest and an even swifter trial.

Through it all, Grace maintains her innocence.

In 2017, Sydney Ryan is a rising documentary filmmaker whose investigations have freed several people accused of crimes. Grace has been writing to Sydney for years, asking for her help. The last letter she received convinces her to make Julian Crist’s murder her next assignment.

Traveling to St. Lucia, Sydney’s first stop is with the head of the investigation division of the St. Lucian police force. From him, she learns the police never had another suspect in Julian’s death. They focused on Grace and no one else. The reason? To keep the crime’s notoriety from deflecting tourists from the island.

Nevertheless, Inspector Pierre agrees to help.

“I’ve gotten a lot of pressure from a group in America that thinks this girl is innocent. Will your documentary show the truth or what they believe the truth to be? Because the truth about Ms. Sebold is overwhelming.”

The inspector has made an understatement.

Soon Sydney discovers a convoluted relationship between Grace and the newlyweds, (Why has Daniel kept in touch with Grace though his wife, for whom she was maid of honor?). She learns more about Grace’s brother, suffering from a degenerative disease. (Why can he overcome his illness only while playing chess? Why does he demand a near-monopoly on Grace’s company?) What does best friend Ellie know about all this? Why was blood found in Grace’s hotel room when Julian died on a hilltop overlooking the sea? A pathologist Sydney talks to reads the St. Lucian autopsy report and says the marks on Julian’s body were made by a right-handed person.

Sydney Ryan is a rising documentary filmmaker whose investigations have freed several people accused of crimes.
Sydney Ryan is a rising documentary filmmaker whose investigations have freed several people accused of crimes.

Grace is left-handed.

Some people won’t talk to her. Others talk too much. Sydney is also fighting her bosses, who wonder if Grace’s documentary will gather enough viewer ratings. They don’t care whether Grace is innocent or not, just how many people watch the show. And there’s their star, Luke Barrington, who hosts their top-rated news show. Luke doesn’t like the fact this newbie filmmaker may steal his spot, and is doing his best to downgrade her project.

Sidney begins to wonder if “fame and fortune are enough, or if the truth is the only thing that matters.”

The documentary airs on national television.

Sydney gets a call from Gus Morelli, a retired policeman currently in a convalescent home recovering from cancer surgery. Gus has seen part of her documentary and it reminds him of another crime, committed years before.

“He’d found inspiration in the most unusual place. A documentary. Somewhere during the fifth hour of the Grace Sebold documentary, he decided that sitting in a hospital bed feeling sorry for himself was no way to chase down someone who was as guilty as sin.”

With the help of the retired cop, who’s given a reason to live by her documentary, Sydney will soon discover who really killed Julian Crist and why Grace has kept quiet about her knowledge of the crime.

The documentary airs on national television.
The documentary airs on national television.

It will come at a cost neither she nor Gus expects.

Interspersed with Sydney’s notes on the script for her documentary, this is a tense thriller as it step-by-step uncovers what she learns and the way she learns it.

The cold-blooded concern of Sidney’s bosses over whether Grace’s story will garner enough ratings is contrasted to Sydney’s own moments of self-doubt that she might be making the film for her own glorification and not to bring justice to Grace.

Gus comes late into the story, over halfway through, but once established, he becomes an important factor, and as strong a character as Sydney. In some ways, he’s more appealing, as a cantankerous ex-cop giving his nurses “fits” because of his own frustration with his illness. Motivated not only by the desire for justice but because he’ll once again be doing what he’s good at, that fact distracts him from the pain of his illness. Gus may be down but he definitely isn’t out. It is he, at last, who uncovers the truth.

The twist of the ending is only one of many through this very entertaining thriller, for just when the reader believes the story is over, and the actual killer has been brought to justice, author Donlea bring about another surprise until there are layers of them.

This novel is a page turner, and that accolade carries to the very last page and the very last line of the story.

Toni V. Sweeney is the author of The Adventures of Sinbad and The Kan Ingan Archives series and also writes under the pseudonym Icy Snow Blackstone. Read More

New York Journal of Books Reviewer Panel consists of a growing team of talented and experienced reviewers with expertise and credentials that are unique among exclusively online book reviews. This panel includes bestselling and award-winning authors, journalists, experienced publishing executives, tenured academics, as well as highly experienced professionals across a number of disciplines and industries. All bring highly relevant expertise and insight to their reviews. Each reviewer writes about books with a singular, unique voice. Together, this chorus is New York Journal of Books’ special strength. NYJB’s catalog of reviews has far more in common with respected print reviews than with any other online-only review. In a world where print book reviews are in rapid decline, NYJB aims to preserve the tradition of excellence in book critique.

206 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All


bottom of page